Overview

The digital marketing world is full of highs and lows, much like a rollercoaster. For social media managers, observing metrics trending downward can be a daunting experience. If this is your current situation, take a deep breath and continue reading. This guide offers actionable steps and insights to diagnose and combat the downturn.

Stay Calm and Strategize

First things first—don’t panic! Social media is inherently volatile, with fluctuations being a natural part of the landscape. Temporary declines can result from a myriad of factors, such as algorithm changes, increased competition, or simply the ebb and flow of user engagement. However, when they are consistently down for three consecutive months, it’s time to rethink your strategy. Here are some tips to troubleshoot and mitigate decreases:

1. Dive into the Analytics

Before you can fix a problem, you need to understand it. This means closely examining metrics like engagement rates, follower growth, reach, impressions, and click-through rates. By analyzing these key data points, you can uncover insights into how your audience is interacting with your content. Are certain types of posts generating more likes, shares, or comments? Is your content reaching the right audience, or do you need to refine your targeting? Understanding these details helps you identify what’s working and what isn’t, allowing you to adjust your approach to maximize your social media impact and drive better results.

1. Time Frame: Identify any particular periods or events that might correlate with the decline. Was there a specific date or week when the metrics began to dip? Can this be linked to any specific event or change in content strategy?
2. Engagement Metrics: Understand which metrics have been impacted the most. Are likes, shares, or comments decreasing? Or is it the reach and impressions that are declining?
3. Content Analysis: Review the performance of your different content types. Are videos, images, or articles more affected than others? For instance, depending on the platform you’re using, certain features may be prioritized by the algorithm over others, such as video content being favored on LinkedIn or trending hashtags gaining more visibility on Twitter. Understanding these platform-specific nuances can help you tailor your posts for maximum reach and engagement.

2. Account for External Factors

Occasionally, external elements like the following are the culprits behind decreasing metrics.

1. Algorithmic Shifts: Social media platforms often tweak their algorithms, which can influence the visibility of your content. To stay ahead, we rely on sites like Social Media Today, which provide updates and insights on algorithm changes across various platforms.
2. Seasonal Trends: Depending on your business, certain times of the year may naturally affect engagement. For instance, B2B companies often experience a slowdown around holidays, while B2C companies may see a surge during these periods due to seasonal promotions and holiday sales.
3. Competitive Actions: Always keep an eye on your competitors. Their campaigns might be overshadowing yours.

You can stay ahead of these external factors by following influencers in the space on LinkedIn and other social platforms. One of our favorites is Annie-Mai Hodge, who posts weekly about social media trends. Subscribing to newsletters from social media companies also keeps you informed of the latest updates directly from the source.

By keeping tabs on these external factors and staying up to date with industry developments, you can make proactive adjustments to your content and ensure you’re staying competitive in an ever-evolving digital landscape.

3. Assess Your Content

Content is the heart of social media, so it makes sense that something about your content may be causing your metrics to shift. Here’s how you can realign if things go south:

1. Relevance: Ensure your content aligns with your audience’s evolving preferences. Is your content resonating with your audience’s current interests and concerns?
2. Quality Over Quantity: Maintain consistent quality in terms of format, frequency, and production values. Have there been any changes in production values, content format, or posting frequency?
3. Maintain Consistency: Avoid unpredictable posting schedules that can confuse your audience. Are you posting regularly, or has there been a dip in activity?

4. Engage Directly with Your Audience

One of the most powerful ways to ensure your content resonates with your audience is to engage with them directly. Direct communication fosters a sense of community and trust while providing invaluable feedback that can inform your content strategy. Here’s how to leverage this interaction for success:

1. Use Interactive Tools: Platforms like Instagram, LinkedIn, and Twitter offer a variety of features, such as polls, surveys, and question stickers, that make it easy to gather feedback. For instance, create a poll asking your audience which topics they find most useful or which content format (e.g., videos, blogs, infographics) they prefer. These tools not only encourage engagement but also offer quick and measurable feedback.
2. Open a Dialogue: Go beyond surface-level interactions and ask your audience direct, open-ended questions. For example, you could post, “What are your biggest challenges when it comes to [relevant industry topic]?” or “What type of content would you like to see more of from us?” These questions invite more thoughtful responses and give your audience the chance to share their pain points, preferences, and ideas.
3. Analyze the Feedback: Once you’ve collected feedback, analyze the responses to identify patterns and trends. Look for commonalities in what your audience enjoys or wants more of and adjust your content strategy accordingly. For instance, if a significant number of respondents express interest in how-to videos or case studies, consider ramping up production in those areas.
4. Create a Feedback Loop: Engaging your audience shouldn’t be a one-time event. Establish a regular cadence of interaction where you consistently ask for feedback and report back on how you’ve implemented it. For example, after conducting a survey and implementing changes based on the results, share an update: “Thanks to your feedback, we’ve started producing more video tutorials—keep an eye out for our latest!”
5. Cultivate Loyalty through Inclusion: By asking for feedback and showing your audience that their input is valued and acted upon, you’re cultivating a sense of ownership and loyalty. They’ll feel more invested in your brand because they can see their influence in the content you produce. This deeper connection can lead to higher engagement rates, more shares, and, ultimately, a more robust community around your brand.

In Conclusion

A downward trend in social metrics doesn’t spell doom for your brand. By embracing a comprehensive, data-backed approach, you can pinpoint areas that need enhancement, revive your strategy, and guide your brand back onto the growth path. In the ever-changing realm of social media, being adaptable isn’t just beneficial—it’s essential.

For more digital marketing tips and insights, subscribe to the Go Fish Digital newsletter!