How to Manage Multiple Agencies for Maximum Success - Go Fish Digital
Request Proposal Toggle Menu

When Having Multiple Agencies Is an Asset + How to Manage Them

When Having Multiple Agencies Is an Asset + How to Manage Them featured cover image

Most destinations don’t have a “too many marketing agencies” problem. They have a too many handoffs problem.

In 2026, marketing and sales complexity is real. More channels, more stakeholder expectations, more pressure to prove impact. The answer isn’t forcing everything through one vendor or stacking specialists until the org chart collapses. The answer is building an agency ecosystem that runs like one connected system: strategy, media, creative, content, research, web, and sales enablement working from the same plan and the same scorecard.

If you’re leading a destination organization (or any organization with multiple audiences and mandates), here’s the modern playbook to follow.

When Having Multiple Marketing Agencies Is the Right Call

Multiple agencies can be an advantage when they solve for real constraints—not preference. You typically need more than one partner when:

  • Your audiences are fundamentally different. Leisure and meetings buyers do not evaluate destinations the same way, and they don’t convert on the same path.
  • Your work is seasonal and episodic. Big campaign moments, RFP surges, major events, or a rebrand often require surge support.
  • You have risk to manage. Brand consistency, stakeholder alignment, compliance, and reputation management require stronger operating discipline than “everyone do their thing.”

The point isn’t to collect agencies. It’s to cover real capabilities, without sacrificing coherence.

The Reality: Integrated Marketing Wins

DMO leaders don’t care how many agencies work with their organization. They care about:

  • Speed to market
  • Message consistency
  • Fewer surprises
  • Measurable outcomes

An integrated system does three things:

  1. Unifies strategy, creative, media, and web around one demand plan.
  2. Simplifies communication and decision-making so work moves faster with fewer loops.
  3. Amplifies performance because insights travel across the system (instead of staying trapped in one channel).

This is how you reduce duplication, stop internal whiplash, and make your budget work harder.

Four Ways a Specialized Business Events Partner Strengthens the Ecosystem (Without Taking It Over)

This section matters for meetings, sports, or group travel. The work is different: longer buying cycles, higher stakes, more stakeholders, and sales teams that need usable tools that connect leisure, group, and business travel, not just awareness.

Here’s how a specialized business events marketing partner should plug into the ecosystem:

  1. Planner perspective without guessing: Business events marketing performs when it’s grounded in how planners actually evaluate destinations: risk, logistics, stakeholder approval, and speed to “next step.” The right partner brings that lens so your content, web experience, and paid strategy don’t drift into consumer-style messaging that doesn’t convert.
  2. Brand extension, not brand reinvention: The goal isn’t to create a separate “meetings brand.” It’s to extend the destination brand into a buyer-ready story for planners—consistent, credible, and built for decision-making.
  3. Collaboration that reduces client load: Specialists should make your internal team’s life easier—not harder. That means proactive coordination, shared timelines, and a single plan that prevents duplicate asks and competing priorities.
  4. Sales enablement that closes the gap: Sales teams need tools that move business: digital sales kits, follow-up sequences, site-visit support, stakeholder one-pagers, and content that answers objections before they become deal-stoppers. Marketing shouldn’t be forced to choose between brand work and sales support—your ecosystem should cover both.

So You Have Multiple Agencies. Here’s How to Manage Them Like One System.

This is where most organizations lose time: unclear ownership, messy workflows, and reporting that can’t be trusted.

1. Set boundaries by outcome, not by channel.

Channel-based ownership (“Agency A owns social, Agency B owns web”) often creates gaps and overlap. Instead, define ownership by outcomes and decision rights:

  • Who owns the demand plan?
  • Who owns messaging and narrative?
  • Who owns conversion paths and web design?
  • Who owns reporting definitions and data measurement?
  • Who is responsible for sales enablement outputs?

You can still assign channels, but the operating model starts with who owns what decision.

2. Align on one source of truth.

Most ecosystem breakdowns come from teams working from different documents. At minimum, your ecosystem needs shared, current versions of:

  • Annual strategy and priorities
  • Campaign briefs and messaging frameworks
  • Content and media calendars (one integrated view)
  • Reporting definitions and KPI glossary
  • Brand standards and approvals workflow

If it isn’t in the source of truth, it doesn’t exist.

3. Install a single planning cadence.

You don’t need more meetings. You need fewer meetings that matter. A simple cadence that works:

  • Monthly: integrated planning + blockers (60 minutes)
  • Weekly (as needed): campaign execution standup (30 minutes)
  • Quarterly: strategy refresh + budget and performance review (90 minutes)

The goal: Decisions move forward, not sideways.

4. Measure what leadership actually needs to know.

If every agency reports differently, leadership can’t make calls with confidence. Today, the core scorecard should include:

  • Demand signals: qualified inquiries, RFP starts/submissions, sales meetings booked
  • Conversion path health: key site actions (venues viewed, specs downloads, contact sales), form completion, time-to-response
  • Efficiency: cost per qualified action, lead quality trends, wasted spend reduction
  • Brand consistency: message adherence and proof points used across channels

Vanity metrics can exist in the background. They do not run the business.

Bonus: Run an annual ecosystem meetup.

Once a year, reset the rules:

  • What worked, what didn’t
  • What roles need tightening
  • What’s changing in the market
  • What success looks like next year

This is how you maintain momentum instead of re-litigating the same issues every quarter.

Example: Since 2017, Atlanta Convention & Visitors Bureau has hosted an Agency Love Fest, bolstered by Chief Marketing Officer Andrew Wilson’s leadership and push for a collaborative dynamic among all the CVB’s partner agencies. Most of the agencies have been working with Atlanta CVB since the first Agency Love Fest, so trust has been built between all, and they have confidence in having the autonomy to do what their mutual client needs.

Get Integrated Support for Tourism + Business Events

If you need travel and business events marketing support that plugs into your existing agency ecosystem or one holistic partner aligning strategy, content, web, media, and sales enablement to drive measurable demand, that’s what Go Fish was built to do.

MORE TO EXPLORE

Related Insights

More advice and inspiration from our blog

View All